This article is from my monthly newsletter - The Newspupper! It's delivered monthly to your inbox. Sign up using the START HERE link on my website's menu. Every month, I share some thoughts on a topic that's been on my mind.
Introduction
Ever felt the jittery excitement and paralyzing fear that comes with stepping into uncharted territory? Imagine asking a human puppy on all fours to give you their paw, or maybe you’re the dog and a handler or an alpha is the one giving you a command. Now picture yourself taking that first leap into the kink community. While you might be afraid, I assure you that on the other side of that fear is something that might just be utterly liberating.
Diving into the world of kink or pup play can feel like standing on the edge of a pool and not knowing whether the water is warm or ice cold, while knowing for sure that you 100% want to be wet. The fear of getting into kink, however, is not usually about the temperature but about the unknown. The unknown looms large, often larger than reality, but that fear stops us in place and keeps us there. It might be fear of judgment, rejection, or failure that holds you back. It might be the fear of the unknown, of undeveloped skills, of doing something wrong, or of just doing something new. But once you take that leap into a pool of water where the temperature is just right, you’re cozy, comfortable and you want to stay. In fact, you just might want to invite others in and start to consider all kinds of activities to do in a pool that’s so right.. In this blog post, I’m going to explore some common fears new pup players and kinksters face and how to overcome them. I hope by the end, you'll see that taking that first step isn’t as daunting as it seems—and can lead to a world of self-discovery and joy.
1. The Fear of Judgment: Will They Think I'm Weird?
"What will people think?"—a question that has crushed more dreams than failure ever could.
The fear of being judged is often the biggest hurdle for aspiring pup players and kinksters. Society has a way of making anything outside the 'norm' seem strange or even wrong. But remember, the kink community is built on acceptance, diversity, and non-judgment. Most people within it have faced the same fears you're experiencing and have found not only acceptance but celebration of their unique interests.
Practical Tip:
Start by joining online forums, like my Support Pup Community, or local groups where you can observe and ask questions. Look for local Pup and Handler Associations or Leather Clubs. Seeing others confidently living their truth can give you the courage to embrace your own.
Statistic:
An article published in The Journal of Sex and Marital Family reported that a wide range of people, from 12% of people who have fantasized about to to 47% of people have experienced kink at some point in their lives, highlighting how common and normalized these interests are.
“Normal is an illusion. What is normal for the spider is chaos for the fly.” – Morticia Addams
2. The Fear of the Unknown: What Am I Getting Into?
The unknown is scary, but so is staying in a kennel/crate when your soul craves to explore.
Starting out in pup play or any kink can feel like wandering in a dark forest without a map. The fear of the unknown is natural, but it can also be a sign that you’re on the brink of something exciting. The key is to educate yourself. The more you know, the less there is to fear. Pup play and kink can look so many different ways - there are playful kinksters, serious ones, switches who like being dominant and submissive, people who don’t like power exchange but enjoy the sensations of kink play on their own.
Practical Tip:
Educate yourself through reputable sources, workshops, or community events. Get to know other people who enjoy the same things as you. Add your interests to your online profiles, and search those of others to see what they might be able to teach you. It’s 100% ok to start off with a lot of questions and seeking experiences without any commitment to play. Knowledge can be the flashlight that will help you navigate the unknown safely and confidently.
“The greatest thing you’ll ever learn is just to love and be loved in return.” – Moulin Rouge
3. The Fear of Not Being 'Good Enough': Can I Really Do This?
Perfection is the enemy of progress—and play. When it comes to pup play or kink, many newcomers worry they won’t measure up to more experienced participants. They might fear making mistakes or being seen as ‘inexperienced.’ But here’s the thing—everyone starts somewhere, and the community is generally very supportive of beginners.
Practical Tip:
Approach your new interest with a learner’s mindset. Attend beginner-friendly events or workshops where you can gain hands-on experience in a safe environment. Reach out to people who do what you want to do and ask them for advice. All of us who have experience were once in your shoes and are often willing to help or point you in the right direction!
“You don’t have to be great to start, but you have to start to be great.” – Zig Ziglar
4. The Fear of Rejection: What If I'm Not Accepted?
Rejection is not the end of the road; it's a redirection to something better. The fear of not being accepted can be daunting. In some cases, people fear rejection from their partner, their friends, or other more experienced kinksters. In pup play, this fear might manifest as worrying that you won’t find a pack, a pup, or a handler who accepts you. It might feel like you won’t find a Dominant or a submissive with compatible interests. Think about the rest of your life - family, work, hobbies, school, etc. Rejection is a part of life, and you’ve probably worked through it before. It may have even been the thing that motivated you to learn or grow in some way. Rejection is hard but having support to hold you and listen to you through it is key! in the kink community, it’s often just a matter of a little time to find the right people who resonate with your vibe. The kink community, like any other one, is a very diverse one with people from all walks of life and with all sorts of combined interests.
Practical Tip:
Don’t be afraid to put yourself out there, but also don’t be disheartened by setbacks. Finding your place can take time, but it’s worth it when you do. Trying to be something or someone else for people will only lead you astray. Be sure of who you are and what you want, tell people, ask them if they know others like you. And, be curious and interested in what might be a surprise.
“Sometimes rejection in life is really redirection.” – Tavis Smiley
5. The Fear of Losing Control: What If Things Go Too Far?
Surrendering control is frightening—but in the right hands or paws, it’s also incredibly freeing.
One of the most significant fears in kink is the fear of losing control—whether that's during a scene, or over your emotions and desires. Sometimes people wonder if it’s actually ok that they are interested in the thing they are interested in. Does anyone ask if it’s ok to be interested in dangerous sports, knitting, video gaming, etc.? Not usually, because it’s not that taboo, although each has its associated risks and dangers. In some cases it’s concussions, long-term injuries like carpal tunnel, or trouble getting out of the gaming chair. It’s important to remember that your goals and desires are ok to pursue if you keep an eye on your health. With kink, it’s the same, keep an eye on your health, on how you feel about the level of control you’re taking on or giving up, and your consent agreements. They are the cornerstones of any healthy kink relationship. Negotiation and clear boundaries are your best tools for managing this fear.
Practical Tip:
Always communicate your limits and establish a safe word before any scene. Trust in your partner(s) is crucial, but so is trust in yourself to know and express your boundaries. Limits and boundaries should be revisited regularly within yourself and with others you play with.
“Control is not leadership; management is not leadership; leadership is leadership.” – Dee Hock
Conclusion
Starting out as a pup player or kinkster is like standing on the edge of a pool, ready to leap into something exhilarating and often unknown. Yes, there are fears, but each one is an opportunity to grow, learn, and discover a community that celebrates your unique desires. By confronting your fears with knowledge, communication, and self-compassion, you'll find that the leap is worth the thrill. There just might be growth and opportunities you never imagined waiting for you.
Remember, fear is only a shadow - of your past, present, and in your future. Shadows disappear when you shine your light on them. Embrace who you are, take that first step, and let the adventure unfold. Your type of kinksters are out there, and they’re waiting to welcome you with open paws or a treat in their hand!
If you need help unpacking your fears or working through them, my coaching might be the catalyst you need to push through them! Book a call with me today to learn more about my coaching! Also, consider joining the Support Pup Community!
Wag more, growl less! Awwwrrrrooooooo!
-Cooper
Comments